Top 10 Must-Try Italian Restaurants in NYC: Where Tradition Meets Flavor
New York City stands as the undisputed capital of Italian dining in America, where the streets are lined with an array of eateries serving everything from iconic pasta dishes and decadent baked clams to slow-cooked ossobuco, luxurious risottos, and golden, bubbling eggplant Parmigiana. The city’s Italian culinary scene is a vibrant tapestry of timeless classics and innovative creations, attracting both locals and travelers eager to savor authentic Italian and Italian-American cuisine. Whether you’re drawn to humble, family-run trattorias with checkered tablecloths, storied restaurants with mahogany-paneled interiors, or modern ristoranti that set new standards in fine dining, New York offers an Italian experience for every palate. Discover the ten most beloved Italian restaurants in New York City today, each celebrated for its unique charm and unforgettable dishes.
The Italian Scene in NYC: Who Makes the List?
Some of the most celebrated Italian restaurants in the city right now include Bamonte's, Brooklyn Roots, Don Angie, Emilio's Ballato, Forsythia, L'Artusi, Lilia, Maialino (vicino), Rezdôra, and Rubirosa. Each offers a distinct slice of Italy right in the heart of New York.
Step Back in Time at Bamonte's
Address: 32 Withers St, Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Founded in 1900, Bamonte’s is one of Brooklyn’s oldest continuously operating Italian eateries. Stepping inside is like entering a cherished family memory—crisp white tablecloths, ornate woodwork, and servers in classic black suits create an atmosphere of vintage elegance, famously featured in TV shows like The Sopranos. Generations of New Yorkers have gathered here to celebrate milestones and everyday victories alike, making it a true institution.
The menu is a love letter to traditional Italian-American cuisine. Signature dishes include the creamy, comforting rigatoni with vodka sauce, luscious spaghetti and meatballs, and tender pork chops bathed in pickled peppers. The baked clams are a must-try starter, while the veal Valdostana embodies old-world indulgence. Don’t leave without trying their off-menu cannoli—customers rave it’s the best in Brooklyn. The all-Italian wine list is approachable, making every meal as celebratory as Sunday dinner with Nonna.
Site: Bamonte's
Address: 8620 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
Since opening its doors in 2019, Brooklyn Roots has quickly become a Bay Ridge favorite for those craving the warmth and comfort of home-style Italian-American cuisine. Led by Chef Thomas Perone, whose family recipes inspire the menu, this cozy spot evokes the feeling of Sunday dinners at grandma’s house—simple, genuine, and utterly delicious.
Diners delight in the robust flavors of the Caesar salad and the silky burrata, while the meatball appetizers are a crowd-pleaser with their delicate texture and rich tomato sauce. For entrees, the chicken Marsala is legendary for its savory mushroom-wine sauce, and the Scarpiarelo is another standout, blending tender chicken with fragrant herbs. The seafood offerings, sourced fresh daily, are equally beloved. The intimate setting makes reservations a must—call ahead, as walk-ins are rare.
Site: Brooklyn Roots
Modern Italian Magic at Don Angie
Address: 103 Greenwich Avenue, Manhattan
Since its debut in 2017, Don Angie has dazzled the West Village with a fresh spin on Italian-American cuisine. Owned by dynamic chef duo Scott Tacinelli and Angie Rito, Don Angie’s innovative approach quickly earned it a Michelin star in 2021. The restaurant’s style fuses tradition with creativity, reflected in both its chic décor and its memorable menu.
Don Angie’s signature pinwheel lasagna for two is an Instagram sensation and a culinary triumph, featuring light sheets of pasta spiraled with rich meat sauce and cheese. Fans also adore the crisp chrysanthemum salad, spicy cantaloupe with prosciutto, and the irresistible stuffed garlic flatbread oozing with cheese. The wine list is exclusively Italian, spotlighting rare gems like a Garganega-based orange wine from the Veneto. Each visit promises a new flavor discovery.
Site: Don Angie
Address: 55 East Houston Street, Manhattan
Serving devoted diners since 1956, Emilio’s Ballato is a true throwback to the golden era of Italian dining in New York. The restaurant’s storied dining room—adorned with crystal chandeliers and vintage memorabilia—has hosted celebrities, politicians, and generations of families. Owner Emilio Vitolo, a legendary host, still greets regulars himself, ensuring every guest feels like family.
The kitchen is famous for its “Veal Chop Antonio”—a juicy, double-cut chop enveloped in a savory sauce with pickled cherry peppers. Other stars include pasta fagioli, spaghetti with shrimp and creamy mushroom sauce, and a soul-satisfying breaded veal cutlet lavished with vodka sauce and crispy prosciutto. The tiramisu earns rave reviews for its airy texture and bold espresso flavor. No reservations are accepted, so timing your visit is key.
Site: Emilio’s Ballato
A Taste of Rome at Forsythia
Address: 9 Stanton Street, Manhattan
Forsythia began as a pandemic pop-up and has since blossomed into one of the Lower East Side’s most beloved Italian restaurants, dedicated to the vibrant flavors of Rome. The welcoming, rustic-chic interior invites guests to linger over housemade pasta and seasonally inspired dishes. Chef-owner Jacob Siwak draws on both his Roman training and New York sensibility to craft a menu that changes with the farmers’ markets.
Highlights include cacio e pepe suppli—crispy arancini with gooey, peppery cheese centers—and short rib-stuffed agnolotti bursting with savory depth. The focaccia, served warm with whipped ricotta and creamy butter, is the stuff of carb-lover dreams. Save room for the honey cake, a much-lauded dessert when available. The wine list is thoughtfully curated to showcase the best of Italy’s diverse regions.
Site: Forsythia
Stylish Pasta Paradise at L’Artusi
Address: 228 West 10th Street, Manhattan
For over a decade, L’Artusi has been a beacon for pasta lovers in the West Village. Established in 2008, the restaurant is renowned for its sleek ambiance and consistently outstanding Italian fare, making it a go-to for special occasions and casual gatherings alike. The open kitchen and buzzing bar add to the lively, welcoming vibe.
Diners rave about the roasted mushrooms—umami-rich and perfectly caramelized—and the creamy burrata served with seasonal accompaniments. L’Artusi’s handmade pastas are the true stars, from spaghetti with crunchy garlic breadcrumbs to the decadent bucatini amatriciana with pancetta and pecorino. For dessert, the olive oil cake, crowned with golden raisin marmalade and crème fraîche mousse, is unforgettable. The restaurant’s vast wine list features rare finds and classic Italian pours.
Site: L’Artusi
Pasta Perfection at Lilia
Address: 567 Union Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Located in a beautifully restored former auto-body shop, Lilia has been redefining Italian dining in Williamsburg since 2016. Helmed by Chef Missy Robbins, a James Beard Award winner, Lilia offers a menu that celebrates regional Italian flavors with a contemporary twist. The airy, sunlit space is always bustling, filled with diners eager for a taste of Robbins’ creative genius.
Lilia is celebrated citywide for its handmade pastas, especially the sheep’s milk cheese agnolotti with saffron and honey, and the mafaldini pasta swirled in a lush Parmigiana sauce. Guests also love the focaccia brushed with green garlic butter and the grilled leg of lamb, masterfully prepared over a wood fire. Beverage lovers will appreciate the all-Italian wine selection, featuring unique varietals like Lambrusco and Teroldego. For a sweet finish, try "The Italian Job": creamy vanilla gelato with fennel pollen, sea salt, and a drizzle of olive oil and honey.
Site: Lilia
Address: 30 East 30th Street, Manhattan
Maialino (vicino), from famed restaurateur Danny Meyer, has relocated to the Redbury Hotel, continuing its tradition of offering soulful Roman cuisine in a warm, inviting setting. Inspired by Rome’s trattorias, Maialino (vicino) captures the essence of Italian hospitality, where meals are always leisurely and full of laughter.
The menu pays homage to Roman classics: the cacio e pepe is creamy and peppery, and the off-menu spaghetti carbonara is a cult favorite, featuring silky egg sauce and crispy guanciale. For mains, the swordfish with roasted tomato, pine nuts, and basil is a standout, as is the signature suckling pig, roasted until the skin is perfectly crisp. The all-Italian wine list is extensive, offering everything from lively Sicilian whites to robust Piedmont reds. Guests can also unwind at the adjacent wine bar, enjoying salumi, panini, and a glass of Italian vermouth.
Site: Maialino (vicino)
Emilia-Romagna’s Finest at Rezdôra
Address: 27 East 27th Street, Manhattan
Opened in 2019 by chef Stefano Secchi, a veteran of Italy’s Michelin-starred kitchens, Rezdôra brings the heart of Emilia-Romagna to Manhattan’s Flatiron District. The name, meaning "queen of the kitchen" in local dialect, honors the region’s matriarchs who are masters of pasta-making.
The pasta menu is a tour de force, offering a $98 tasting that features house specialties like the uovo raviolo—a giant egg yolk-filled pasta in sage butter—and handmade tagliatelle with ragu. The bistecca per due, a succulent steak for two, also draws rave reviews. The intimate, softly lit space creates an ideal backdrop for savoring these northern Italian flavors. Advance reservations are essential due to high demand.
Site: Rezdôra
Legendary Pizza and More at Rubirosa
Address: 235 Mulberry Street, Manhattan
Since 2009, Rubirosa has been a Nolita landmark, beloved for its inviting energy and wide-ranging Italian-American menu. Founded by the son of the legendary Staten Island pizza maker Giuseppe Pappalardo, the family legacy lives on in every slice and plate. The restaurant’s colorful, casual dining room is always buzzing, drawing pizza fans from all corners of the city.
Rubirosa is famous for its thin-crust tie-dye pizza, a vibrant combination of tomato sauce, basil pesto, and fresh mozzarella that’s as photogenic as it is delicious. The housemade pastas, antipasti, and classic Italian soups are equally impressive. Pair your meal with a glass of COS Cerasuolo di Vittoria from Sicily for the ultimate experience. Be prepared for a wait—Rubirosa’s popularity means reservations are scarce, but walk-in spots are frequently available.
Site: Rubirosa
all.sign in to leave a review
